Trend followers stage recovery as stretched S&P, Nasdaq longs fuel gains
When InvestingPro’s Fair Value model flagged The RealReal (NASDAQ:REAL) as significantly overvalued on January 4, 2025, the luxury consignment platform’s stock was trading at $9.50. Five months later, this bearish call has proven remarkably accurate, with shares declining 43% to $5.37. This success story demonstrates how InvestingPro’s sophisticated valuation models can help investors identify both overvalued and undervalued opportunities. For investors seeking similar opportunities, check out our regularly updated Most overvalued list.
The RealReal operates as an online marketplace for authenticated luxury resale goods, positioning itself in the growing sustainable luxury segment. When InvestingPro’s models identified the overvaluation, the company was showing mixed signals. Despite experiencing significant stock price gains in late 2024, fundamental challenges persisted, with quarterly revenue of $600.48 million and concerning EBITDA losses of $23.20 million.
The Fair Value analysis predicted a downside of approximately 41%, with a target price near $5.60. This bearish outlook materialized as predicted, with the stock steadily declining over the following months. The accuracy of this call is particularly noteworthy given the stock’s volatile nature, having shown dramatic swings of over 100% in the months preceding the analysis.
Recent developments have validated InvestingPro’s cautious stance. While Q1 2025 results showed some improvements, including the third straight quarter of positive EBITDA and revenue growth to $616.72 million, management’s weak guidance sparked concerns. Multiple insider sales, including significant dispositions by the former CEO and CFO, further supported the bearish thesis. Despite BTIG raising their price target to $9, the stock has continued to trade closer to InvestingPro’s fair value estimate.
InvestingPro’s Fair Value methodology combines multiple valuation approaches, including discounted cash flow analysis, peer comparisons, and historical trading ranges. This comprehensive approach, coupled with real-time market data and fundamental analysis, helps investors identify pricing inefficiencies before the broader market recognizes them.
For investors looking to access similar actionable insights, InvestingPro offers a suite of advanced tools including real-time fair value updates, insider trading alerts, and comprehensive fundamental analysis. The platform’s proven track record in identifying mispriced stocks like REAL demonstrates its value for investors seeking to make more informed investment decisions.