Tesla could be a $10,000 stock in a decade, says longtime bull Ron Baron
In a striking validation of data-driven investment analysis, shares of Steven Madden, Ltd. (NASDAQ:SHOO) have surged 66.47% since InvestingPro’s Fair Value model identified the footwear company as significantly undervalued in late June 2025. This remarkable return in just under five months demonstrates how identifying mispriced stocks through comprehensive valuation analysis can lead to exceptional investment outcomes. Investors seeking similar opportunities can explore today’s most promising candidates on InvestingPro’s Most undervalued list.
Steven Madden , a $2.77 billion market-cap company in the Consumer Cyclicals sector, designs and markets fashion-forward footwear and accessories. When InvestingPro’s Fair Value model flagged SHOO as undervalued on June 25, 2025, the stock was trading at $23.35 – a significant discount to its calculated Fair Value of $35.81, suggesting a potential upside of 53.36%. This identification came after a challenging period for the stock, which had experienced negative returns in five of the previous six months, including declines of over 20% in February and April 2025.
The company’s fundamentals at the time showed annual revenue of $2.28 billion and EBITDA of $266.2 million, with earnings per share at $2.34. Despite these solid numbers, market sentiment remained negative, creating the price-value disconnect that InvestingPro’s algorithms detected.
The investment thesis proved remarkably accurate. From the June 25 signal to November 14, SHOO shares climbed steadily from $23.35 to $38.19, delivering a 66.47% return – even exceeding the model’s projected upside. The stock saw particularly strong gains in August (+20.97%) and September (+16.06%) 2025, with the momentum continuing through November. This performance coincided with several positive developments, including better-than-expected quarterly earnings results and multiple analyst upgrades.
Recent months have seen several catalysts supporting the stock’s ascent. Steven Madden beat Q2 and Q3 earnings estimates, with the latter causing a notable share price jump. The company’s strategic acquisition of Kurt Geiger was well-received by analysts, with BTIG, Telsey Advisory, Williams Trading, and Citi all raising their price targets. BTIG increased its target to $43 in its most recent update, suggesting potential for further gains despite the already impressive rally.
InvestingPro’s Fair Value analysis works by aggregating multiple valuation methodologies to determine a stock’s intrinsic worth. The model incorporates discounted cash flow projections, comparable company analyses, dividend discount models, and analyst consensus targets, while also considering the company’s financial health score – which for Steven Madden stood at a solid 2.94 out of 3. This comprehensive approach helps identify temporary mispricings that the market often corrects over time.
The Steven Madden success story illustrates the power of data-driven investment analysis available through InvestingPro. Beyond Fair Value indicators, subscribers gain access to comprehensive financial health scores, real-time earnings tracking, and fundamental data analysis that can help identify similar opportunities before the broader market catches on. With tools designed to cut through market noise and focus on intrinsic value, investors can make more informed decisions based on quantitative analysis rather than market sentiment. Learn more about InvestingPro to discover how these powerful tools can enhance your investment strategy and help identify the next potential multi-bagger in your portfolio.