Fed’s Powell opens door to potential rate cuts at Jackson Hole
Introduction & Market Context
Kingstone Companies Inc (NASDAQ:KINS), a northeast regional property and casualty insurer, presented its Q1 2025 investor slides highlighting significant growth in its core New York business amid favorable market conditions. The company, with a market capitalization of $256 million, has strategically positioned itself to capitalize on competitor withdrawals from the New York insurance market.
The insurer reported a 23% increase in core direct written premiums compared to Q1 2024, building on momentum from its strong Q4 2024 performance when it exceeded analyst expectations with EPS of $0.46 against a forecasted $0.42. Kingstone’s stock has shown remarkable strength, delivering a 256.92% return over the past year according to recent data.
As shown in the following overview of Kingstone’s key metrics:
Strategic Focus on Core Business
Kingstone has implemented a deliberate strategy to concentrate on its core New York business while reducing exposure in non-core markets. This approach has been particularly timely given the significant market opportunity created when competing carriers exited New York State in July 2024, representing a potential $200+ million market opportunity within Kingstone’s established footprint.
CEO Meryl Golden emphasized the significance of this market shift, stating: "I believe the current market changes present us with the greatest profitable growth opportunity that Kingstone has ever experienced!"
The company’s strategic focus is evident in its shifting business mix, with core business increasing from 76% to 87% of policies-in-force between December 2023 and March 2025, while non-core business decreased from 14% to just 4%.
The following chart illustrates Kingstone’s direct premium written trajectory, showing the growth in New York business and strategic reduction in non-core operations:
This strategic shift has yielded impressive results in loss experience, with the core business consistently outperforming non-core operations. By Q1 2025, both segments achieved a 26.7% net loss ratio, representing significant improvement for the core business and dramatic improvement for previously troubled non-core operations.
The following chart demonstrates this performance improvement:
Financial Performance Highlights
Kingstone’s Q1 2025 financial results show substantial improvement across multiple metrics compared to the same period in 2024. Direct premiums written increased to $58.2 million from $49.3 million, while net premiums earned rose to $43.5 million from $28.8 million. The company’s annualized return on equity reached 20.8%, up from 16.4% in Q1 2024.
Operating net income nearly tripled to $2.4 million compared to $853,000 in the prior year period, while book value per share doubled to $5.57 from $2.80 a year earlier.
The following table provides a comprehensive overview of Kingstone’s key financial metrics:
Kingstone’s investment portfolio continues to provide consistent income, with net investment income increasing to $2.0 million in Q1 2025 from $1.5 million in Q1 2024. The company maintains a high-quality portfolio with 83% of fixed income holdings rated A or higher, or held as U.S. Treasuries.
The portfolio composition and yield trends are illustrated in the following chart:
Risk Management & Operational Efficiency
Kingstone has maintained disciplined expense management while growing its premium base. The net underwriting expense ratio remained stable at 31.3% for Q1 2025, continuing a multi-year trend of improvement from 41.0% in 2021.
The company’s pricing strategy has been aggressive but effective, with average core personal lines business renewal premiums increasing 18.7% in Q1 2025 compared to Q1 2024. This pricing discipline has helped Kingstone stay ahead of inflation while ensuring properties are insured at current replacement cost.
Kingstone also emphasizes its conservative reinsurance program, which includes property catastrophe coverage, quota share treaties, and excess of loss arrangements. The company has managed its reinsurance costs effectively, with cumulative risk-adjusted rate changes comparing favorably to industry benchmarks.
Forward-Looking Guidance
Based on anticipated net premiums earned of approximately $184 million, Kingstone provided optimistic guidance for 2025, projecting:
These projections reflect management’s confidence in continuing the positive momentum established over the past several quarters. The guidance aligns with the company’s strategic focus on its core New York market and suggests continued strong financial performance.
Kingstone’s Q1 2025 presentation reinforces the company’s successful execution of its strategic initiatives, with financial results showing substantial improvement across multiple dimensions. The insurer appears well-positioned to capitalize on favorable market conditions in its core New York territory while maintaining disciplined underwriting and expense management.
Full presentation:
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.