Earnings call transcript: Tilly’s Q4 2025 sees significant earnings miss

Tilly’s Inc (TLYS) reported a significant earnings miss for the fourth quarter of 2025, with an actual EPS of -$0.45 compared to the forecasted -$0.24. The company’s revenue also fell short of expectations, coming in at $147.3 million against a forecast of $159.9 million. Following the announcement, Tilly’s stock dropped 9.09% in aftermarket trading, closing at $3, near its 52-week low of $3.22. According to InvestingPro data, the company’s market capitalization has shrunk to $92.57 million, with the stock showing significant volatility and a concerning 50.21% decline over the past year.

Key Takeaways

• Tilly’s missed both EPS and revenue forecasts for Q4 2025.
• The stock dropped 9.09% in aftermarket trading, reflecting investor concerns.
• Physical and e-commerce sales both saw significant declines.
• The company plans merchandising changes and inventory reductions for fiscal 2025.
• Tilly’s faces a challenging retail environment and economic pressures.

Company Performance

Tilly’s experienced a tough fourth quarter, with total net sales decreasing by 14.9% year-over-year. Both physical store sales and e-commerce sales saw declines, down 13.7% and 17.8% respectively. The company’s gross margin also decreased slightly to 26% of net sales, compared to 27% in the previous year. These results highlight ongoing challenges in the retail sector, exacerbated by economic concerns affecting consumer spending.

Financial Highlights

• Revenue: $147.3 million, down 14.9% year-over-year
• Earnings per share: -$0.45, missing the forecast by $0.21
• Gross margin: 26% of net sales, down from 27%
• Net loss: $13.7 million

Earnings vs. Forecast

Tilly’s reported an EPS of -$0.45, missing the forecast of -$0.24 by a significant margin. Revenue also fell short, coming in at $147.3 million against a forecast of $159.9 million. This represents a major miss for the company, indicating deeper financial challenges.

Market Reaction

Following the earnings announcement, Tilly’s stock fell 9.09% in aftermarket trading to $3. This drop reflects investor disappointment with the company’s performance, as the stock approaches its 52-week low of $3.07. The negative reaction is indicative of broader concerns about Tilly’s ability to navigate a challenging retail environment. InvestingPro analysis suggests the stock is currently undervalued, though investors should note the company’s weak financial health score of 1.0 out of 5. InvestingPro subscribers have access to 12 additional key insights about TLYS, including detailed valuation metrics and growth prospects.

Outlook & Guidance

Looking ahead, Tilly’s has provided guidance for Q1 2026, estimating net sales between $105 million and $111 million, with a comparable store net sales decrease of 8% to 3%. The company expects a pretax loss between $20 million and $17 million, with an estimated loss per share of $0.58 to $0.68. InvestingPro data reveals concerning trends, including rapid cash burn and two analyst downward revisions for the upcoming period. For comprehensive analysis of TLYS and 1,400+ other stocks, including detailed financial health metrics and expert insights, consider accessing the full Pro Research Report on InvestingPro. Tilly’s plans to improve sales and inventory efficiency, with merchandising changes expected to yield results by July.

Executive Commentary

CEO Hezi Shekhed stated, "By July, we should see the results of the merchant team effort," indicating confidence in the company’s strategic changes. CFO Michael Henry added, "Our goals for fiscal twenty twenty five are to deliver improved sales and inventory efficiency," highlighting the company’s focus on operational improvements.

Risks and Challenges

• Economic concerns continue to impact consumer spending, posing a risk to sales.
• The retail environment remains challenging, with strong competition and changing consumer preferences.
• Tilly’s must successfully implement its merchandising changes and inventory reductions to improve margins.
• The company faces potential supply chain disruptions and cost pressures.

Q&A

During the earnings call, analysts inquired about the impact of tariffs, with management indicating minimal effects. Questions also focused on the company’s e-commerce strategy, with Tilly’s using a hybrid store and distribution center model for fulfillment. Management expressed confidence in managing without accessing their credit facility, despite current financial challenges.

Full transcript - Tillys (TLYS) Q4 2025:

Conference Operator: Good day, and welcome to the Tilly’s Fourth Quarter and Full Year twenty twenty four Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in listen only mode. After today’s presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Gar Jackson, Investor Relations.

Please go ahead.

Gar Jackson, Investor Relations, Tilly’s: Good afternoon, and welcome to the Tilly’s fiscal twenty twenty four fourth quarter earnings call. Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, will discuss the company’s business and operating results. Then he and Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, will host a Q and A session. For a copy of Tilley’s earnings press release, please visit the Investor Relations section of the company’s website at tilley.com. From the same section, shortly after the conclusion of the call, you will also be able to find a recorded replay of this call for the next thirty days.

Certain forward looking statements will be made during this call that reflect Tilly’s judgment and analysis only as of today, 03/12/2025, and actual results may differ materially from current expectations based on various factors affecting Tilly’s business. Accordingly, you should not place undue reliance on these forward looking statements. For a more thorough discussion of the risks and uncertainties associated with any forward looking statements, please see the disclaimer regarding forward looking statements that is included in our fiscal twenty twenty four fourth quarter earnings release, which is furnished to the SEC today on Form eight K as well as our other filings with the SEC referenced in that disclaimer. Today’s call will be limited to one hour and will include a Q and A session after our prepared remarks. I will now turn the call over to Mike.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Thank you, Gar, and to everyone on the call for joining us today. The fourth quarter of fiscal twenty twenty four was disappointing, particularly following what was our best comp sales performance since 2021 during the third quarter. We made several organizational changes in our merchandising team during the fourth quarter with the goal of beginning to stabilize and then turning our sales trajectory around. We believe in our merchandising team’s abilities. Merchandising has not been easy when many of our best traditional brand partners have been facing their own significant operating challenges.

We are adapting our brand and assortment mixes to attempt to improve sales and changes will continue as we progress through fiscal twenty twenty five. We believe our spring assortment is on trend based on the brief period of positive comps we saw in stores when weather turned warmer. We have planned meaningfully reduced inventory commitments throughout fiscal twenty twenty five compared to fiscal twenty twenty four to target faster turns and further improvement in product margins. We have reassessed inventory needs by product category and set targets that aim to move us back toward historical norms that this company has been able to produce repeatedly in its past. Beyond merchandising adjustments, we’ve targeted significant expense reductions during fiscal twenty twenty five from the combination of continued diligent scrutiny of every store lease decision, strict management of store distribution and corporate payroll and negotiated reductions in contractual commitments across operational departments with the support of many of our business partners.

At the same time, we plan to continue investing in our business in terms of expanded marketing efforts, carefully selected new store opportunities and pursuit of operating efficiencies, all with the goal of improving our performance. Now I will turn to the specifics of our fiscal twenty twenty four fourth quarter operating performance compared to fiscal twenty twenty three’s fourth quarter before sharing our fiscal twenty twenty five first quarter outlook. Total net sales of $147,300,000 decreased by 14.9% compared to the fourth quarter of fiscal twenty twenty three. Last year’s fourth quarter contained an extra week, which accounted for $5,700,000 in total net sales. Total comparable net sales, including both physical stores and e commerce, for the comparable thirteen week period ended 02/01/2025 decreased by 11.2%.

Total net sales from physical stores decreased by 13.7% and represented 73.5% of our total net sales compared to 72.6% of our total net sales last year. On a comparable thirteen week basis, net sales from physical stores decreased by 9.8. E commerce net sales decreased by 17.8% and represented 26.5% of total net sales compared to 27.4% of total net sales last year. We ended the fiscal year with two forty total stores, a net decrease of eight stores compared to the end of fiscal twenty twenty three after having closed 10 stores during the fourth quarter. Gross margin, including buying, distribution and occupancy expenses was 26% of net sales compared to 27% of net sales last year.

Despite our sales miss and significantly increased inventory valuation reserves, product margins still improved by 190 basis points compared to last year, primarily due to higher initial markups. Buying, distribution and occupancy costs deleveraged by two ninety basis points collectively despite being $1,500,000 below last year due to carrying these costs against lower net sales. Total SG and A expenses were $52,400,000 or 35.6% of net sales compared to $55,200,000 or 31.9% of net sales last year. The decrease in SG and A was primarily due to the extra week in last year’s fourth quarter, which added an estimated $2,600,000 to last year’s SG and A. Pretax loss was $13,400,000 or 9.1% of net sales compared to 6,900,000 or 4% of net sales last year as a result of the combination of factors just noted.

Income tax expense was $200,000 despite our pretax loss position due to the continuing impact of a full noncash deferred tax asset valuation allowance. Last year’s fourth quarter included the original noncash deferred tax asset valuation allowance charge of $15,400,000 resulting in income tax expense of $13,600,000 despite our pretax loss position. Net loss was $13,700,000 or $0.45 per share compared to $20,600,000 or $0.69 per share during last year’s fourth quarter, which included the previously mentioned valuation allowance charge. Turning to our balance sheet, we ended the fiscal year with total cash and marketable securities of $47,000,000 and available undrawn borrowing capacity of $48,000,000 under our asset backed credit facility. Total inventories were 9.5% higher than at the end of fiscal twenty twenty three.

However, as of 03/01/2025, total inventories were 6.1% below last year’s level as of the comparable date due to specific actions taken to address this issue. Total capital expenditures in fiscal twenty twenty four were $8,200,000 compared to $14,000,000 in fiscal twenty twenty three. Turning to the first quarter of fiscal twenty twenty five. The trend of our business has improved from our fourth quarter performance with total comparable net sales for fiscal February ended 03/01/2025, decreasing by 5.7% relative to the comparable period of last year and with stronger performance when the weather has turned warmer. As a result and based on current historical trends, we currently estimate that our total net sales for the first quarter will be in the range of approximately $105,000,000 to $111,000,000 translating to a comparable store net sale decrease in the range of approximately 8% to 3% respectively compared to last year.

We expect our SG and A expenses to be approximately $42,000,000 to $43,000,000 in the absence of any non cash asset impairment charges which may arise and our pretax loss to be in the range of $20,000,000 to $17,000,000 respectively. Our estimated loss per share is expected to be in the range of $0.68 to $0.58 for the first quarter with a near zero income tax rate due to the continuing impact of the previously noted valuation allowance on deferred tax assets. We currently expect to have two thirty eight total stores operating at the end of the first quarter compared to two forty six at the end of last year’s first quarter. As our cash naturally ebbs and flows with the cadence of the fiscal year, we expect to end the first quarter with total cash and marketable securities of approximately $25,000,000 to $30,000,000 before it moves back higher at the end of the second quarter amid the early stages of the back to school season. At our fiscal February comparable net sales trend, we believe we can operate without accessing our credit facility at any time during fiscal twenty twenty five.

We expect to operate with lower unit inventories than last year throughout fiscal twenty twenty five as I noted earlier. Additionally, we expect to finalize an extension of our asset backed credit facility with Wells Fargo Bank through July 2028 before the end of the first quarter. In closing, our goals for fiscal twenty twenty five are to deliver improved sales and inventory efficiency with reduced expenses. It may prove difficult to achieve amid current economic concerns, but we believe we have the plans and teams in place that can deliver results. We look forward to sharing our progress with you as we go through the year.

Operator, we’ll now go to our Q and A session.

Conference Operator: Our first question comes from Jeff Van Sinderen with B. Riley Securities. Please go ahead.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Okay. Thanks for taking my question. I guess the first one I had was just around tariff impact or potential tariff impact. Maybe you can just lay out for us, I know you do have some private label product, but I don’t think there is a tariff impact on that. Can you just refresh our memories around potential tariff impact?

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: Yes, Joe, at the

Conference Operator: moment, not

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: Go ahead, guys. Let me take it. This is, so we looked into it by the way, Monday and it will be a minor effect about very few of the vendors we’re using for private label. Actually, it’s only one at this stage indicated that they might have to split the increased cost with us. And it’s not significant with this particular vendor, but this is the information we have as of right now.

I expect it to have some effect. It’s hard to quantify at this stage.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Okay. And then as you’re sort of thinking about the Doge backdrop that we’re in and the potential impact to the consumer overall, the recession word is sort of being talked about. I guess, how are you thinking about that? Do you feel like the changes you’re making to the merchandise assortment can offset that?

Gar Jackson, Investor Relations, Tilly’s: I guess, just any thoughts

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: around that? Yes, yes. That is the hope, right? I mean, the headwinds we’re going to have like everybody else does, we’d be there. And the hope is that by the time we get our merchandising everything in line, we should be able to mitigate it, but there’s no guarantee.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Yes. Okay. And then I just kind of have a more strategic or structural question for you. I’m just kind of looking at your cash balance and CapEx. How are you thinking about store openings this year?

Are you planning to open any or are we in more of closure mode at this point? What should we anticipate for CapEx this year? And then I also wanted to ask you, and this is something that has been done a little bit more, but I apologize for the multipart question here, but on e commerce, I just wonder if it might make sense for you to fulfill e commerce out of your stores and not have a separate e commerce fulfillment center?

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: Sure. I will start from the last one. We do a hybrid. We feel from the stores as well as we do from Icahn. In the event that we don’t have it at Icahn Building, it comes from the closest store to the customer.

So at this stage, it’s not something we are considering doing complete shipping from the stores. On the first question on the CapEx, we are still opportunists. Any situation that we believe the ROI is going to be short, We’ll capitalize on that. We did open two stores recently and they’re both very profitable. And I think we will see great results from those two.

We do have a kind of a place marker for additional stores in case we find the right location that makes sense. But overall, I think my goal will be to probably close more unprofitable stores than open new ones.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Yes, Jeff, I’ll add some details to that. So one store opened already about just last week actually. There’s a second one that’s planned to open in August currently. We know of seven store closures that will take place as of now, three in the first quarter and four in the second quarter. That’s what we know as of this moment.

And as Hazy referenced, the placeholder that we have in our budget is just five stores. So it’s a limited number. And as you noted, we’ll be very opportunistic about that. It doesn’t mean we’re going to open five. We only have two as we have right now.

And we have seven closures. There could be more closures as we go through the year and work through all of our lease decisions, but that’s the latest information we have as of today.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: And sorry, Mike, on that, how many lease decisions do you have this year?

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Well, just like every other recent year, we’ve been renegotiating leases for several years and as we do these things, they tend to go one to two to three years at a time. So every year there’s roughly about 80 lease decisions to make it seems and that’s right in the neighborhood of how many we’ll have to deal with this year.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Okay, fair enough. Thanks for taking my questions. I’ll let someone else jump in.

Conference Operator: And the next question comes from Matt Koranda with Roth Capital. Please go ahead.

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: Hey guys, just backing up to the fourth quarter results and the comp, just wanted to see sort of if you could maybe just give a little commentary on the down 11% comp for the fourth quarter, it’s a little below the range you gave and just want to see kind of what might have fallen short kind of later in

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: the quarter? Go ahead, Eze.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Yes, we started off really go ahead, Eze.

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: No, no, you can take that.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Okay. Obviously, when we released Q3 earnings and gave our outlook, we acknowledged what our comps were through the early stage of the quarter. So November was the weakest month of the quarter by far. We were down 21% in fiscal November and then we were down 6% to 7% in each of December and January, just to give you the cadence of the quarter.

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: Okay. All right. Got you. And then just in terms of the trends quarter to date, I know the release says sort of minus 6% roughly in terms of comps in February. We’re expecting minus 8% to 3%.

Maybe just can you talk about the sensitivities in the range in terms of what brings us to the bottom and the top end of that range? And then just any way you can unpack sort of any of the trends at all that you saw in February. I know a lot have been kind of calling out some softness in the month of February progressively as we went through the month, but just wanted to see if you could note any kind of changes that you were seeing in your business.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Sure. So in fiscal February, week three was the softest of the month and then in week four is when we got a nice little heat wave, especially here in California. And so I noted in our prepared remarks that we did see positive comps in our stores. That was a four day period when we had really nice seasonal weather and saw a pretty significant change in the trajectory of our business and with a lot of parts of our spring assortment really popping during that period. So in the aggregate, fiscal February finished at minus 5.7% and that was inclusive of that short window of time where we saw positive comps in our stores.

Gives us some cautious optimism that as we get into better, more warmer weather as we get deeper into the quarter that our assortment seems to be on trend and we should see some response from it as we get into more spring seasonal weather. We do have a later Easter this year. So it is going to get a little worse before it gets better because of the shift out of Easter. Easter was March 31 last year versus April 20 this year. So our outlook range kind of encapsulates right where we are.

The cautious optimism I mentioned of seeing some warmer weather and better performance can lead us towards the upper end and kind of nothing really got better than what we’re anticipating and knowing that things are going to get tougher in March because of the later Easter, the typical Easter shift that happens every year, one way or the other, that could lead us towards the bottom end. 2022 was the last fiscal year where Easter is in the precise location as it is this year. So that’s what we’re using to model kind of how the cadence of the quarter goes. Okay. All

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: right. Very helpful, Mike. Thanks. And then maybe just for Hesi, can you just talk higher level about sort of what inning we are in terms of the merchandising and assortment change? When will the new team sort of fully have their fingerprints on all products that are in the stores?

Maybe just level set everybody on sort of when we should expect that productivity to come into play?

Hezi Shekhed, Co Founder, Executive Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Tilly’s: Sure, sure, absolutely. Yes, absolutely. Let me take you back a little bit. By the way, as you know, we missed the merchandise for Christmas fourth quarter, and that was the reason I changed the top merchant. We realigned the merchant team.

We have a lot of good talent there, but the direction was wrong. And I think by July, we should see the results of the merchant team effort. I also got to remind you what happened here is we had to mark down a lot of the merchandise because it was just the wrong direction. And due to that, that affects everything, including your comps, because you’re comping dollars. And we are going to dismerchandise, we’re clearing it.

As you can see, our inventory is down, and we expect to clear all that by the same time. We should see some results in July.

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: Okay. That makes sense. Appreciate that, Hazy. And then maybe just last one for Mike. Just,

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: can you

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: just comment on what’s embedded in the cash balance guide at the end of the quarter in terms of inventory? Are we assuming that the inventory balance is down year over year at the end of the quarter? Maybe just talk about sort of where you see inventory normalizing. And then, I guess the other kind of higher level question on the balance sheet is just like what would cause you to tap the credit facility? At what point will we see you drawing on that if and when?

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Sure. So as I noted in our prepared remarks, we’re planning to operate with lower unit inventories all year long. We took a really hard look at our inventory needs by product category, being a lot more strict about how we’re viewing that. We’ve simply been buying too much in recent years. And so worked real hard with the teams to realign our inventory plans kind of from a bottoms up perspective by product category and feel confident that we have a good plan in place to have inventory very well managed as we go throughout the year.

So we should be below last year’s levels all year long at the end of each quarter. And that’s been planned into our merch plan budget for the year. So long as we don’t have something approaching about a minus 10 comp consistently all year long, we should not have to access our credit facility. As I mentioned, based on our February comp run rate of minus 5.7, we could run that all year long and we would not have to touch our credit facility at all. So we have a borrowing free balance sheet and so long as we don’t have a deterioration in our comp trend from where we are and closer to about that minus 10 level, we shouldn’t have to access our credit facility at any point in time.

Matt Koranda, Analyst, Roth Capital: Okay, super clear. I appreciate it guys. I’ll leave it there.

Conference Operator: And the next question comes from Jeff Van Sinderen with B. Riley Securities. Please go ahead.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Just wanted to sort of follow-up around the thinking on the credit line and the cash balance. And just wondering if there are other areas you feel you can reduce SG and A given kind of the rate run rate of the business?

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: So we have, that was in our prepared remarks as well. We’ve renegotiated a lot of contractual commitments with the assistance of several of our business partners. We had to absorb another year of minimum wage increases that for the first quarter would all things being equal cost us about $400,000 but with another swing at trying to be super tight on our payroll metrics, we actually expect our payroll dollars to be down in the first quarter. Despite that minimum wage increase. Hesi and I ran every single department head over the calls with their departmental budgets.

We have looked at literally everything. So we expect to see some favorability as we go through our lease decisions. We expect to see some favorability out of payroll in all facets, as I mentioned, whether it’s store payroll, distribution or corporate office because of the changes we’ve made and plans we have in place. And we’ve looked at every major contractual commitment that we have, looking for anywhere that we can squeeze expense and those things are factored in, and also have an impact on our ability to manage our way through the year without accessing our credit facility because of it.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Okay. So is it would it be fair to say, Mike, that if your business starts to turn up, which you sound cautiously optimistic that it can, and hopefully around the summertime, it will. And let’s just if we assume for a second that you are comping positive in third quarter, let’s say, or second quarter, would it be fair to think that with the reductions you’ve made so far that the SG and A dollars can be down year over year? I just want to kind of clarify the thinking on

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: that. That would be our expectation, yes, that we could manage through this year with a lower total dollar value of SG and A than what we had in 2024.

Jeff Van Sinderen, Analyst, B. Riley Securities: Okay, great to hear. Thank you.

Conference Operator: This concludes our question and answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Mike Henry for any closing remarks.

Michael Henry, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, Tilly’s: Thank you all for joining us on the call today and we look forward to sharing our results with you as we go through the year. Thank you.

Conference Operator: The conference is now concluded. Thank you for attending today’s presentation. You may now disconnect.

This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.