CLSA lowers Treasury Wine stock rating amid increased short interest

On Tuesday, CLSA analysts downgraded Treasury Wine Estates Ltd . (ASX:TWE) stock from High-Conviction Outperform to Outperform. The decision comes amid increased short interest, which has led to further underperformance by the company. According to InvestingPro data, the stock has declined nearly 29% over the past six months and is currently trading near its 52-week low of $4.93. The stock’s relative price-to-earnings ratio is now at a 48% discount compared to the ASX200 industrials, excluding financials.

The analysts noted that the current stock price appears to be factoring in a 40% downgrade to earnings per share, a move they consider aggressive given the ongoing weakness in the US market and uncertainty in China. Despite these challenges, CLSA maintains a price target of AUD13.20 for Treasury Wine Estates.

The analysts expressed confidence in their adjusted net tangible asset valuation of AUD8.70, describing it as a "scorched earth" scenario that could attract potential acquirers. According to InvestingPro’s Fair Value analysis, the stock appears undervalued at current levels. They highlighted upcoming catalysts for the stock, including a market update on its luxury business scheduled for this month and the fiscal year 2025 results in August. Both events could positively influence the stock if management reassures the market about potential earnings downside.

Treasury Wine Estates’ stock performance has been under scrutiny due to these factors, leading to the revised rating. The company’s ability to navigate market challenges and provide positive updates could play a significant role in shaping its future valuation.

In other recent news, Treasury Wine Estates has been the focus of varying analyst opinions. RBC Capital initiated coverage on the company with an Outperform rating, setting a price target of AUD11.00. Their analysis highlights Treasury Wine Estates’ strategic positioning in the luxury wine market, particularly with its flagship brand, Penfolds, and the potential to capitalize on regulatory changes in the U.S. and China. RBC Capital also noted that the company’s stock is trading at a significant discount compared to its historical average, suggesting it is undervalued. On the other hand, Citi downgraded Treasury Wine Estates from Buy to Neutral, adjusting the price target to AUD10.50 from AUD13.85. Citi expressed concerns about the company’s performance in the Americas and the broader alcohol industry’s structural challenges. However, they acknowledged potential positive factors such as improved synergies from the DAOU acquisition and favorable currency exchange rates, which are expected to impact financials more significantly by fiscal year 2026. These recent developments reflect differing perspectives on the company’s growth potential and market positioning.

This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.