RLI’s SWOT analysis: insurance firm’s stock faces growth challenges

RLI Corporation, a specialized insurance company with a market capitalization of $6.19 billion, has demonstrated resilience in a competitive market environment, but faces challenges in maintaining its growth trajectory. Currently trading near its 52-week low, the company’s recent financial performance and market position reveal a complex picture of strengths and vulnerabilities that warrant closer examination. According to InvestingPro analysis, RLI shows signs of being slightly undervalued based on its Fair Value estimates.

Financial Performance

RLI Corp reported a strong second quarter for 2025, with operating earnings per share (EPS) of $0.84, surpassing both analyst estimates of $0.80 and the consensus of $0.79. This outperformance was primarily attributed to a lower-than-anticipated Property loss ratio, driven by fewer catastrophe losses and stronger favorable prior period development (PPD). The company’s trailing twelve-month revenue growth of 11.69% demonstrates solid momentum, though InvestingPro data indicates net income is expected to decline this year. Additionally, the company saw better performance in its Surety and Casualty loss ratios.

Despite the positive earnings report, RLI’s top-line growth has shown signs of deceleration. Gross written premiums remained flat for the second quarter of 2025, falling short of the expected 5% growth projection. This stagnation was largely due to a decline in Property premiums and lower-than-expected growth in the Casualty segment, although the Surety segment exceeded expectations.

The company’s book value saw a modest increase of 1.0% in August 2025, reflecting ongoing stability in its financial position. However, this growth rate was less pronounced compared to some industry peers, indicating potential challenges in maintaining its historical growth trajectory.

Segment Analysis

RLI’s business is divided into three main segments: Property, Casualty, and Surety. Each segment has shown distinct performance characteristics in recent quarters.

The Property segment has been a point of concern, experiencing contraction over recent quarters due to increased market competitiveness. This trend has been particularly impactful on growth, as the second quarter is seasonally significant for this business line. The segment’s performance, while better than projected in terms of loss ratio, has been a drag on overall premium growth.

In contrast, the Surety segment has been a bright spot for RLI, exceeding growth expectations and demonstrating strong performance. This success in Surety has helped to partially offset the challenges faced in the Property segment.

The Casualty segment has shown mixed results. While it has contributed to the company’s solid performance, there are indications of caution regarding ongoing loss cost pressures. In the fourth quarter of 2024, the Casualty accident year loss ratio was higher than projected, suggesting potential headwinds in this area.

Market Position and Valuation

Analysts believe that RLI shares should trade at a premium compared to peers, citing the company’s strong underwriting and book value growth track record. The company has maintained dividend payments for 50 consecutive years, currently offering a 3.92% yield. Trading at a P/E ratio of 19.07x and approximately 3.7 times book value, these multiples are considered fair when compared to peer medians of 3.0 times book value and 17 times EPS. For deeper insights into RLI’s valuation metrics and growth potential, investors can access comprehensive analysis through InvestingPro, which offers additional ProTips and detailed financial metrics.

RLI’s market performance is underpinned by its exemplary underwriting track record and management’s ability to navigate market conditions effectively. The company has demonstrated skill in capitalizing on hard market conditions while exercising caution when necessary.

Future Outlook

Looking ahead, RLI faces both opportunities and challenges. The company’s strong performance in the Surety segment presents a potential avenue for growth, while the Casualty segment may offer opportunities if loss cost pressures can be effectively managed.

However, the ongoing contraction in the Property segment remains a concern, potentially limiting overall growth prospects. The company will need to navigate the competitive landscape carefully to maintain its market position and continue its track record of book value growth.

Analysts maintain a cautiously optimistic outlook on RLI, with most recent ratings indicating a Market Perform stance. This reflects a balanced view of the company’s strong fundamentals and the challenges it faces in a dynamic insurance market.

Bear Case

How might the Property segment contraction impact RLI’s overall growth?

The contraction in RLI’s Property segment poses a significant challenge to the company’s overall growth prospects. As this segment has been declining over recent quarters due to increased market competitiveness, it has already contributed to flat gross written premiums in Q2 2025, falling short of growth expectations.

The Property segment’s importance is magnified by its seasonal significance in the second quarter. If this contraction continues or worsens, it could lead to sustained pressure on RLI’s top-line growth. This may result in a prolonged period of stagnant or even declining overall premiums, potentially impacting the company’s market share and financial performance.

Furthermore, the Property segment’s challenges could have ripple effects on other areas of the business. Resources may need to be reallocated to address the segment’s issues, potentially diverting attention and investment from growth opportunities in other segments. This could lead to a more conservative approach to risk-taking and expansion, limiting RLI’s ability to capitalize on market opportunities.

What risks does RLI face from ongoing loss cost pressures in Casualty?

The Casualty segment presents another area of concern for RLI, particularly due to ongoing loss cost pressures. In the fourth quarter of 2024, the Casualty accident year loss ratio was higher than projected at 74% versus the estimated 65%, indicating a need for caution in this area.

If these loss cost pressures persist or intensify, they could lead to deterioration in the Casualty segment’s profitability. This may necessitate increases in loss reserves, which would negatively impact earnings and potentially the company’s book value. Moreover, if RLI needs to raise premiums to offset these increased costs, it could face challenges in customer retention and new business acquisition, especially in a competitive market environment.

The situation in the Casualty segment also raises questions about RLI’s pricing strategy and risk assessment processes. If the company is consistently underestimating loss costs, it may need to reassess its underwriting approach, which could lead to a period of adjustment and potentially lower growth as it recalibrates its risk models.

Bull Case

How does RLI’s strong underwriting track record position it for future success?

RLI’s exemplary underwriting track record is a significant strength that positions the company well for future success. This track record demonstrates the company’s ability to effectively assess and price risks, which is crucial in the insurance industry.

The company’s consistent underwriting performance has contributed to its strong book value growth over time. This financial stability provides RLI with a solid foundation to weather market fluctuations and potentially capitalize on opportunities that may arise during periods of market dislocation.

Furthermore, RLI’s underwriting expertise could be leveraged to expand into new markets or product lines. The company’s proven ability to manage risk effectively could give it an edge when entering new areas, potentially opening up additional avenues for growth.

RLI’s strong underwriting performance also contributes to its premium valuation compared to peers. This higher valuation could provide advantages in terms of capital raising or potential mergers and acquisitions, giving the company flexibility in its strategic decisions.

What opportunities exist for RLI in the Surety and Casualty segments?

Despite challenges in the Property segment, RLI has shown strong performance in its Surety segment, which exceeded growth expectations in recent quarters. This success presents an opportunity for the company to further expand its presence in the Surety market, potentially offsetting some of the pressure from the Property segment.

The Surety segment’s outperformance suggests that RLI has developed competitive advantages in this area. By focusing resources and strategic efforts on this segment, the company could potentially capture additional market share and drive overall growth.

In the Casualty segment, while there are ongoing loss cost pressures, there may also be opportunities. If RLI can effectively manage these pressures through improved risk assessment and pricing strategies, it could potentially improve profitability in this segment. Moreover, as some competitors may struggle with similar challenges, RLI’s strong underwriting capabilities could allow it to selectively grow in areas where others are pulling back.

Additionally, both the Surety and Casualty segments may benefit from broader economic trends. As infrastructure spending increases and construction activity rebounds, demand for surety bonds could grow. Similarly, evolving liability landscapes in various industries could create new opportunities in the Casualty space for insurers with strong risk assessment capabilities.

SWOT Analysis

Strengths:

• Strong underwriting track record
• Consistent book value growth
• Outperformance in Surety segment
• Management’s ability to navigate market conditions

Weaknesses:

• Property segment contraction
• Slower top-line growth than expected
• Higher-than-projected Casualty loss ratios
• Flat gross written premiums in recent quarters

Opportunities:

• Potential for further growth in Surety segment
• Possibility to leverage underwriting expertise in new markets
• Selective growth in Casualty amid competitor challenges
• Potential benefits from increased infrastructure spending

Threats:

• Increased market competitiveness, especially in Property segment
• Ongoing loss cost pressures in Casualty
• Potential for continued Property segment decline impacting overall growth
• Market valuation already reflecting premium over peers

Analysts Targets

• JMP Securities: Market Perform (August 11, 2025)
• JMP Securities: Market Perform (July 22, 2025)
• Citizens Bank: Market Perform (April 24, 2025)
• JMP Securities: Market Perform (March 3, 2025)
• JMP Securities: Market Perform (January 23, 2025)

This analysis is based on information available up to August 14, 2025. To stay ahead of market movements and make informed investment decisions about RLI, consider exploring InvestingPro’s comprehensive research platform. The service offers exclusive insights, Fair Value estimates, and detailed financial health scores, along with access to Pro Research Reports that transform complex Wall Street data into actionable intelligence.

InvestingPro: Smarter Decisions, Better Returns

Gain an edge in your investment decisions with InvestingPro’s in-depth analysis and exclusive insights on RLI. Our Pro platform offers fair value estimates, performance predictions, and risk assessments, along with additional tips and expert analysis. Explore RLI’s full potential at InvestingPro.

Should you invest in RLI right now? Consider this first:

Investing.com’s ProPicks, an AI-driven service trusted by over 130,000 paying members globally, provides easy-to-follow model portfolios designed for wealth accumulation. Curious if RLI is one of these AI-selected gems? Check out our ProPicks platform to find out and take your investment strategy to the next level.

To evaluate RLI further, use InvestingPro’s Fair Value tool for a comprehensive valuation based on various factors. You can also see if RLI appears on our undervalued or overvalued stock lists.

These tools provide a clearer picture of investment opportunities, enabling more informed decisions about where to allocate your funds.

This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.