Why Walmart Continues to Outperform Other Retail Stocks Despite Industry Pressures

In a retail landscape where most traditional brick-and-mortar stores struggle against e-commerce giants and face mounting pressures from inflation and changing consumer habits, Walmart (WMT) stands as a remarkable outlier.

While competitors like Target have seen their stock prices plummet by over 33% in the past year, Walmart has delivered impressive returns of nearly 30% over the same period.

This divergence isn’t coincidental—it reflects fundamental differences in how Walmart operates, adapts, and positions itself in the modern retail ecosystem.

As the world’s largest retailer with over 5,200 domestic locations and nearly 5,600 stores outside the United States, Walmart has transformed from a simple discount retailer into a sophisticated omni-channel powerhouse that continues to defy traditional retail expectations.

Walmart as a Retail Powerhouse: The Differentiating Factors

Scale and Market Dominance

Walmart’s sheer scale sets it apart from every other retailer in ways that create insurmountable competitive advantages. With annual revenues exceeding $693 billion and a market capitalization of over $810 billion, the company operates at a level that dwarfs most competitors—Target, by comparison, has a market cap of just $40 billion.

This massive scale allows Walmart to negotiate better prices with suppliers, invest heavily in technology and infrastructure, and weather economic storms that would devastate smaller retailers. The company’s ability to leverage its size becomes particularly apparent when examining its supply chain efficiency and pricing power, which enable it to maintain margins even during inflationary periods.

The company’s dominance extends beyond mere numbers. Walmart processes more transactions than almost any other retailer, giving it unparalleled data insights into consumer behavior and spending patterns. This information advantage allows the company to optimize inventory, predict trends, and adjust strategies faster than competitors.

Additionally, Walmart’s geographic footprint means that approximately 90% of the U.S. population lives within 10 miles of a Walmart store, creating a distribution network that even Amazon struggles to match for certain product categories.

Perhaps most importantly, Walmart has successfully shed its image as merely a discount retailer. The company now attracts higher-income shoppers who previously might have avoided its stores, expanding its addressable market significantly. This demographic shift, combined with strong e-commerce growth that now accounts for nearly one-fifth of total sales, demonstrates Walmart’s ability to evolve beyond its traditional boundaries while maintaining its core value proposition.

Technological Innovation and Adaptation

Unlike many traditional retailers caught flat-footed by digital transformation, Walmart has aggressively invested in technology and innovation. The company’s recent partnership with Avery Dennison for RFID implementation in fresh food departments exemplifies its commitment to operational excellence through technology. This system will revolutionize inventory tracking, reduce waste, and improve the shopping experience—advantages that smaller retailers simply cannot afford to implement at scale. Walmart’s willingness to experiment and fail fast has led to successful initiatives like its Walmart+ subscription service, which continues to add paying subscribers and create a more loyal customer base.

The company’s data monetization business, highlighted by UBS as a potential long-term growth driver, represents another dimension of Walmart’s evolution. By leveraging its massive transaction data and customer insights, Walmart is creating entirely new revenue streams that don’t depend on traditional retail margins. The recent $4.4 billion in high-margin advertising revenue from sellers on its e-commerce platform demonstrates how Walmart is transforming into a technology-enabled retail platform rather than just a store operator. This diversification of revenue sources provides resilience against traditional retail headwinds.

Furthermore, Walmart’s strategic partnerships, including collaborations with technology companies like OpenAI, position it at the forefront of AI-driven retail innovation. These investments in artificial intelligence and machine learning capabilities enhance everything from supply chain optimization to personalized marketing, creating efficiencies that translate directly to the bottom line. While competitors struggle to keep pace with basic e-commerce capabilities, Walmart is already implementing next-generation technologies that will define retail’s future.

Macro Headwinds and Potential Correction Risks

Valuation Concerns and Market Expectations

Despite Walmart’s impressive performance and strategic positioning, several warning signs suggest the stock may face a correction in the near term. Trading at a PE ratio of 38.4x—significantly higher than Target’s 10.4x—Walmart’s valuation has reached levels that leave little room for error. This premium valuation assumes continued exceptional execution and growth, but as one analyst noted, "At 45x earnings multiple, Walmart now has no margin for error, and the road ahead looks bumpy."

The stock’s recent run-up has been fueled by multiple expansion rather than just earnings growth, a situation that typically precedes corrections when growth expectations aren’t met.

The company’s PEG ratio of 3.37 suggests the stock is potentially overvalued relative to its expected growth rate, especially concerning given the challenging retail environment ahead. With the Federal Reserve maintaining higher interest rates and consumer spending showing signs of weakness, Walmart’s premium valuation becomes increasingly difficult to justify. The upcoming November 14, 2025 earnings date will be crucial—any disappointment in guidance or same-store sales growth could trigger a sharp repricing of the stock. Historical patterns show that retail stocks trading at such elevated multiples often experience 15-20% corrections when growth momentum slows.

Additionally, the concentration of recent gains in "other" revenue categories like advertising and data services, while impressive, adds uncertainty to the growth story. These nascent businesses, though high-margin, are unproven at scale and face increasing competition from established players like Amazon and Google. If growth in these areas disappoints or traditional retail operations weaken simultaneously, the current valuation premium could evaporate quickly.

Economic and Competitive Pressures

The macroeconomic environment presents substantial challenges that even Walmart’s strengths may not fully offset. With consumer confidence wavering and credit card delinquencies rising, the retail sector faces headwinds that historically impact even the strongest players. Target’s recent announcement of 1,800 corporate job cuts amid stagnant sales serves as a warning of what may come for the broader retail sector.

While Walmart has thus far navigated these challenges better than peers, its exposure to lower-income consumers—who are disproportionately affected by inflation and economic uncertainty—creates vulnerability to a consumer spending pullback.

Competition is also intensifying from unexpected quarters. Dollar stores continue to proliferate, potentially eroding Walmart’s traditional value proposition, while Amazon’s continued investment in physical stores and same-day delivery capabilities threatens Walmart’s convenience advantage. The recent partnership between OpenAI and other retailers suggests that Walmart’s technological advantages may be shorter-lived than currently priced into the stock.

International expansion, once a growth driver, faces headwinds from geopolitical tensions and currency fluctuations that could impact earnings.

The company’s significant debt load, with a debt-to-equity ratio of 68.72%, while manageable at current interest rates, could become problematic if economic conditions deteriorate or refinancing becomes necessary at higher rates.

Share buybacks, which have supported the stock price, are slowing due to the elevated share price—the company hasn’t been able to repurchase shares at the historical pace since 2019. This removal of a key technical support for the stock, combined with stretched valuations and challenging comparisons from the previous year’s strong performance, creates a setup where a correction becomes increasingly probable, potentially in the 20-30% range if multiple catalysts converge.

Conclusion

While Walmart remains fundamentally different from other retail stocks due to its scale, innovation, and strategic positioning, investors should recognize that even the best companies can face corrections when valuations become disconnected from underlying fundamentals. The company’s transformation into a technology-enabled omni-channel retailer is impressive, but at current prices, much of this success appears already priced in. Prudent investors might consider waiting for a pullback before initiating or adding to positions, as the risk-reward profile at these levels appears less favorable than it has been in recent years.

***

This article was written by Shane Neagle, editor in chief of The Tokenist. To get trade ideas and pre-market insights delivered to your inbox every morning premarket, click here to sign up for Bull Whisper (free), brought to you in partnership with The Tokenist.