Victory Capital Holdings Inc . (NASDAQ:VCTR) announced in its latest earnings call robust financial results for the fourth quarter of 2023, including the highest level of gross sales and net long-term flows in over a year. The company closed the year with assets under management (AUM) totaling $166.6 billion, marking a strong foundation for 2024. The improving sales environment was tempered by client caution, with an increase in cash and cash equivalent investments. Victory Capital's fee rate climbed to 52.1 basis points, contributing to solid revenue growth. A record amount of capital was returned to shareholders in 2023, alongside a fortified balance sheet. The investment performance was impressive, with a significant portion of AUM surpassing benchmarks. Looking forward, the company is poised to execute strategic transactions and is committed to organic growth and technology investments.
Key Takeaways
- Victory Capital ended 2023 with strong AUM growth, reporting $166.6 billion in AUM.
- The company saw its best gross sales and net long-term flows in over a year.
- Despite an improving sales environment, clients favored cash and cash equivalents.
- A fee rate increase to 52.1 basis points led to solid revenue performance.
- Victory Capital returned a record amount of capital to shareholders and strengthened its balance sheet.
- Significant portions of AUM outperformed benchmarks, reflecting strong investment performance.
- The company is optimistic about 2024, with plans for strategic transactions, organic growth, and technology investments.
Company Outlook
- Victory Capital is optimistic about the sales and flows environment for 2024.
- Potential acquisitions are on the horizon, particularly in the fixed income and private credit asset classes.
- The company plans to enhance its ETF business by launching more ETFs and building out an ETF-only salesforce in 2024.
Bearish Highlights
- Clients remain cautious, with a preference for cash and cash equivalent investments.
- The macro environment presents challenges, as investors are holding onto cash.
Bullish Highlights
- Victory Capital's investment franchises, including RS and WestEnd, saw positive flows and outperformed benchmarks.
- WestEnd Advisors experienced a 35% increase in financial advisors allocating assets to their strategies in 2023.
- The brokerage platform launched by Victory Capital has shown positive client engagement and asset growth.
Misses
- No specific details were provided on assets and accounts in their direct channel.
- There were no bid-ask spread expectations discussed for M&A activities.
Q&A Highlights
- The company's approach to acquisitions focuses on enhancing overall company value rather than targeting specific asset classes.
- Victory Capital is exploring options to expand its fixed income capabilities, including acquisitions or partnerships.
- Growth potential was highlighted for WestEnd Advisors, RS Global, and the institutional distribution channel.
- Plans to improve the direct channel with an expanded product set and enhanced client experience were discussed.
In conclusion, Victory Capital's earnings call painted a picture of a company with a strong financial standing and a clear strategy for growth. With a record capital return to shareholders and a solid performance in investment management, Victory Capital is looking ahead to 2024 with a focus on strategic acquisitions, organic growth, and technology investments while navigating a cautious investment climate.
InvestingPro Insights
Victory Capital Holdings Inc. (VCTR) has not only demonstrated a robust financial performance in the latest quarter but also shows several promising indicators for potential investors. According to InvestingPro data, the company boasts a market capitalization of approximately $2.4 billion, indicating a significant presence in the investment management sector. The P/E ratio, a measure of a company's current share price relative to its per-share earnings, stands at a reasonable 11.56, with an adjusted P/E ratio for the last twelve months as of Q3 2023 at an even more attractive 10.32. This suggests that the company's earnings are strong relative to its share price.
In terms of profitability and growth, Victory Capital shines with a gross profit margin of 54.79% over the last twelve months, pointing to efficient operations and a solid grasp on managing expenses relative to revenue. The company's operating income margin of 42.82% further underscores this efficiency.
InvestingPro Tips highlight several key strengths for Victory Capital. The management's aggressive share buyback strategy could be a signal of confidence in the company's value, while the consistent increase in dividends for five consecutive years reflects a commitment to returning value to shareholders. Furthermore, the fact that six analysts have revised their earnings upwards for the upcoming period suggests a positive outlook on the company's future financial performance.
For those interested in further insights, there are additional InvestingPro Tips available for VCTR at https://www.investing.com/pro/VCTR. Among these, it is worth noting that Victory Capital's liquid assets exceed its short-term obligations, indicating good liquidity and financial health. The company is also trading near its 52-week high and has provided a strong return over the last three months, which could interest both value and momentum investors.
To access a full range of insights and analysis, consider subscribing to InvestingPro. Use the coupon code PRONEWS24 to get an additional 10% off a yearly or biyearly Pro and Pro+ subscription. With this subscription, you will gain access to a wealth of additional InvestingPro Tips to guide your investment decisions in Victory Capital and other companies.
Full transcript - Victory Capital Holdings Inc (VCTR) Q4 2023:
Operator: Good morning, and welcome to the Victory Capital Fourth Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All callers are in a listen-only mode. Following the company's prepared remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session. I will now turn the call over to Mr. Matthew Dennis, Chief of Staff and Director of Investor Relations. Please go ahead, Mr. Dennis.
Matthew Dennis: Thank you. Before I turn the call over to David Brown, I would like to remind you that during today's conference call, we may make a number of forward-looking statements. Please note that Victory Capital's actual results may differ materially from these statements. Please refer to our SEC filings for a list of some of the risk factors that may cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed on today's call. Victory Capital assumes no duty and does not undertake any obligation to update any forward-looking statements. Our press release that was issued after the market closed yesterday disclosed both GAAP and non-GAAP financial results. We believe the non-GAAP measures enhance the understanding of our business and our performance. Reconciliation between these non-GAAP measures and the most comparable GAAP measures are included in tables that can be found in our earnings press release and in the slide presentation accompanying this call, both of which are available on the investor relations portion of our website at ir.vcm.com. It is now my pleasure to turn the call over to David Brown, Chairman and CEO. David?
David Brown: Thanks, Matt. Good morning and welcome to Victory Capital's fourth quarter 2023 earnings conference call. I'm joined today by Michael Policarpo, our President, Chief Financial and Administrative Officer, as well as Matt Dennis, our Chief of Staff and Director of Investor Relations. I will start today by providing an overview of the fourth quarter and full year. After that, I will turn the call over to Mike to review the financial results in detail. Following our prepared remarks, Mike, Matt, and I will be available to take your questions. The quarterly business overview begins on Slide 5. I'm pleased to report that we ended 2023 on a high note. During the year's final quarter, we achieved the best level of gross sales as well as net long-term flows in more than a year. This helped us end 2023 with $166.6 billion in assets under management, providing a strong jump off point for 2024. With interest rates appearing to have plateaued, the general sales environment is starting to feel a bit more constructive from an activity standpoint. However, the general sentiment of most clients is still cautious. This cautious approach and the ability to earn a substantial yield in cash and cash equivalent type investments has continued to produce record levels of investor assets in the cash asset class. That said, longer term we are very optimistic about the prospect for assets coming out of cash and entering into more risk-based asset classes, but the specific timing of those assets moving is uncertain. Our fee rate rose to 52.1 basis points in the quarter. This was slightly higher than the average rate realized in the prior quarter, which helped produce a very solid revenue number for the quarter. GAAP operating income and adjusted EBITDA both grew in the fourth quarter from third quarter levels. Our margins were strong for the quarter and for the full year. For the quarter, adjusted EBITDA margin expanded to 52.3%, and for the full year it grew to 50.9% compared with 49.6% in 2022. The consistency of our margins quarter to quarter, year-to-year, and during one of the tougher cycles for our industry validates the strength and resiliency of our business platform and our team's ability to execute. Shifting to capital, we returned more capital to shareholders during 2023 than in any other year in our history. And at the same time, we accumulated additional excess cash in our balance sheet to enhance our future financial flexibility. We also continued to invest in our organic growth. Specifically, we invested in product development through the launch of new products in 2023 and preparations to launch additional new products in 2024. Additionally, we invested in our technology and data platforms, as well as expanding our digital marketing capabilities for key distribution channels, and we continue to hire in numerous areas of our business. Turning to Slide 7, our investment performance remains strong with 70% of our AUM in mutual funds or ETFs earning overall four or five star ratings. This is broadly diversified spanning across 42 different products. Compared against benchmarks, our one-year performance at the end of December dips slightly from above 70% at the end of November. Importantly, over the three and five year periods, 62% and 84% of our total AUM has outperformed their respective benchmarks. And perhaps more importantly, over the trailing three year period, 44% of our AUM in mutual funds and ETFs was ranked in the top quartile of the industry by Morningstar. Drilling down further into performance, 95% of fund AUM managed by our Victory Income Investors franchise held four or five star Morningstar rankings as of December 31st. This is encouraging as we anticipate investors will be pivoting their portfolios into longer duration fixed income products as the outlook for interest rates changes. Moreover, products such as our Victory RS Global Fund, RSGGX, remains five-star overall rated and through year-end, this fund ranked in the top decile over the one, three, and five-year periods. And even more impressively, for the 10-year period it was ranked in the first percentile. On Slide 8, you can see our capital allocation strategy. We continue to favor strategically investing for the growth, given we believe this is how we will create the greatest amount of shareholder value over the long term. We remain flexible and opportunistic in our approach. During the fourth quarter, we repurchase more shares in the open market than in any other quarter following the third quarter when we focused on accumulating cash. We further increased cash on hand during the fourth quarter as well to ensure that we have financial flexibility in the future to execute on our strategy. For 2023, we returned a record amount of capital to shareholders and at the same time, we're able to strengthen the balance sheet. Our return of capital was made up of $158 million in share repurchases and $85 million in the form of cash dividends. Taken together, this $243 million of capital return in 2023 exceeded the prior year by 21%. In December, the board approved a new $100 million share repurchase program allowing us to remain flexible, and yesterday we announced a 5% increase in our quarterly cash dividend. Meaningful progress continues to be made with our M&A diligence initiatives and 2024 looks like it is setting up to be a year where we potentially could execute a strategic transaction. Although I have nothing specific to report today, I can say that I am extremely optimistic about our ability to execute. We look forward to updating you on our progress here as we move through our process. Turning to Slide 9, here is an update on the ownership of our private equity shareholders. Since commencing share sales in late 2021, 33.4 million shares have been sold or distributed through today. This is noteworthy and that it represents more than 50% of our current outstanding shares and 77% of our current public flow. As a result, the liquidity and trading volume have improved in our shares, and there has been sufficient market demand for our shares to absorb this significant shift to a much higher proportion of public ownership. At year end, our employees and directors held almost 20% of their diluted equity in our firm, reinforcing our unique ownership culture. This ownership is extremely broad throughout the firm, with approximately 86% of our employees owning the VCTR stock. Just as important as the VCTR stock ownership is for our culture, is the personal investments of our employees in our own Victory Products. At 12/31, 2023 our employees have invested over $200 million in Victory Products all by choice side-by-side with our clients. Taken together, at year-end our 481 employees had approximately $600 million of skin in the game between ownership of the VCTR stock and our Victory Products. This is particularly noteworthy considering there was no employee equity ownership in our company prior to the management buyout in 2013. Crestview Partners is now the sole remaining private equity shareholder with a current position of 11.6 million shares, representing approximately 18% of the outstanding shares. With that, I will turn the call over to Mike to go through the quarter's financial results in greater detail. Mike?
Michael Policarpo: Thanks, Dave, and good morning, everyone. The financial results review begins on Slide 11. AUM grew to $166.6 billion at the end of the year. This was up 9% from the beginning of the year and it was also a 9% increase from $153.5 billion at the end of the third quarter. The point-to-point increase in AUM was driven by market strength primarily in November and December. Average AUM, which is how our fees are primarily determined, declined quarter over quarter. This was partially offset by the better average fee rate and resulted in revenue for the quarter of $205.8 million, compared with $209.7 million in the third quarter. For the full year, revenue was $821 million. Adjusted EBITDA was $107.6 million in the fourth quarter, marking the highest quarterly level of the year. Margins expanded by 120 basis points in the quarter, reaching 52.3%, and for the full year adjusted EBITDA margin was 50.9%, up 130 basis points from 49.6% for 2022. Fourth quarter GAAP net income rose to $55 million or $0.82 per diluted share, up from $52 million or $0.77 per diluted share in the third quarter. And ANI with tax benefit was $1.15 per diluted share. We ended the quarter with $124 million in cash, which was up from $108 million in cash at the end of September and $85 million higher than at the start of the year. In the fourth quarter, we made the final earn-out payment of $36.4 million for the USAA Asset Management Acquisition, fulfilling our full obligation and removing that liability from our balance sheet. As previously discussed in our last call, we monetized our interest rate swap locking in our gain on that instrument, which will be realized in the form of lower interest expense through the end of the original term in July of 2026. We returned $80 million in capital to shareholders in the quarter. For the full year, we returned $243 million in capital to shareholders, while at the same time improving our net leverage ratio to 2.0 times at year end. The 5% increase in our quarterly dividend to $33.5 announced yesterday will be payable on March 25th to shareholders of record on March 11th. Turning to Slide 12, our AUM remains very balanced from a distribution channel perspective with the percentage mix being very consistent over short and longer periods of time. Slide 13 illustrates how net long-term flows steadily improved in the second half of the year. Investor activity was well diversified with our institutional channel generating positive net flows in the fourth quarter. You can see from the chart that we also gained some traction in gross sales in the fourth quarter and achieved our highest level of gross sales in more than a year. Additionally, with redemptions holding steady, this resulted in our best quarter of long-term net flows in more than a year. Looking to 2024, we are confident that our investments made to enhance organic growth have us well positioned to benefit when the macro environment gets more constructive for risk assets. As Dave highlighted, we have very competitive investment performance and a number of our investment franchises were flow positive for the quarter and for the year. That list includes WestEnd Advisors, RS Global, Trivalent Investments, and New Energy Capital. To drill down on WestEnd a bit more, in 2023 we increased the number of financial advisors allocating assets to their strategies by 35%. This fortifies an already strong foundation of advisors who tend to increase their clients' allocations to WestEnd products over time. We're also casting a wider net with the addition of WestEnd's products to seven new platforms since the acquisition. Revenues are highlighted on Slide 14. Firmwide average fee rate remains steady throughout 2023, covering around 52 basis points, which is within our expected range. Most of the movement associated with our firmwide fee rate is attributable to shifts in asset class, vehicle, and distribution channel mix. Slide 15 illustrates how our operating expenses calibrate with revenue and earnings variability. This is a key feature of our platform that results in our consistently strong margins. Cash compensation expenses were down slightly, in line with lower revenue quarter-over-quarter and represented 22.8% of revenue. Additionally, we experienced lower non-personnel operating expenses compared with the third quarter. Distribution and other asset-based expenses declined $1.7 million, in line with lower average AUM for the quarter. Certain non-cash expenses, such as depreciation and amortization declined from Q3 and the change in value of contingent consideration realized in the quarter declined compared with the prior quarter. Our depreciation and amortization declined $4.3 million from the third quarter. This was due to higher than normal amortization in the prior period related to the previously disclosed divestment and consolidation of our INCORE franchise in the third quarter. These declines were partially offset by higher general and administrative expenses in the quarter, which was driven by $2.4 million of one-time costs associated with the monetization of the interest rate swap and slightly higher marketing and promotional expenses. On slide 16, we cover our non-GAAP metrics. Adjusted net income was $67.4 million. Adjusted EBITDA was $107.6 million and was the highest level of the year. For the full year period adjusted EBITDA was $418 million and adjusted EBITDA margin for the year was 50.9%. Although the margins are in excess of our long-term guidance, we are not changing our current guidance of 49%. We think it is prudent to stay at this level to maintain the flexibility to invest in our platform. Moreover, as we have stated in the past, the margins will fluctuate quarter-to-quarter based on the timing and nature of investments. Finally, turning to Slide 17, while we did not pay down any debt in 2023, our net leverage ratio improved by nearly half a turn during the year. Reflecting cash accumulation and higher run rate EBITDA, our net debt to leverage ratio at year end was 2.0 times compared with the 2.4 times at the beginning of the year. Our $100 million revolver remains undrawn and GAAP operating cash flow was $97 million in the fourth quarter and $330 million for the year. That concludes our prepared remarks. I will now turn it back over to the operator for questions.
Operator: Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Ken Worthington from JP Morgan. Please go ahead.
Michael Cho: Hi, good morning, Dave and Mike. This is Michael Cho. I'm in for Ken today. Thanks for taking my questions here. My first one is just on the sales and flows environment that you called out. You found it fairly off speed in terms of improving gross sales and flows in 4Q, and you also called out institutional, the institutional channel as well. I guess my question is, one, has that kind of momentum and client discussions continued year-to-date 2024? And two, as we can see it in the aggregate numbers, but from your perspective, where are you seeing the most improvement relative to, let's say, prior quarters?
David Brown: Good morning. As you stated, our fourth quarter definitely we saw a pickup. If you look at our gross sales, you'll get our net sales definitely have improved and has consistently improved. In my prepared remarks, I made mention of the environment is getting a little bit better. I think until rates there's a clear vision of when rates are going to come down or when they're going to stabilize. I don't think we're going to see material movements. As far as the first quarter of 2024, we have seen some reallocations to the positive and we've seen some clients pull back as well. So nothing materially has changed in the first quarter from the fourth quarter, but when we look out in 2024 and going into 2025, we're quite optimistic about assets coming into asset classes where we have exposure and we think there's a lot of money sitting in cash as everybody knows. And at some point when rates come down, some of those assets are going to move and they're going to move into asset classes where we have really competitive investment performance and really good distribution. So quarter-to-quarter it's going to be hard to predict, but when we look in years, when we think about 2024 and we think about 2025, we're quite optimistic.
Michael Cho: That's great. Thank you for that. And just to follow-up, I just want to touch on organic investments that you discussed as well. I mean, clearly, 2023 was a year of organic investment as usual, and you called out some more ahead in 2024. So, I'm just kind of curious, just given that dynamic environment that we just talked through, like, where are you focused on in terms of organic investment initiatives for the year ahead? Thanks.
David Brown: So a number of areas we're reinvesting. I'd start off in distribution and partnering with our distribution partners in different channels. So a big push to build the distribution pipes, if you will, to be available when significant assets are moving. So we spent a lot of time and invested dollars into those areas. Data analytics and technology is another area that we focused on. And then the third area is our direct business and we've launched the brokerage platform and we continue to invest there. We are consistently investing. We've consistently invested through this cycle. We haven't invested anymore, and we haven't invested really any less. One of the benefits of our platform and the way we're set up is that, we have not had to pull back, we have not had to make cuts. In fact, we probably reinvested in our platform in 2023 more than we have in the history of our organization. And so, I think that's one of the real benefits that we have on the platform that we have and still maintaining the margins that we have. In fact, this quarter, as we all know, we posted in excess of 50% operating margins.
Michael Cho: Great. Thank you.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Craig Siegenthaler from Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Craig Siegenthaler: Good morning Dave, Mike. Hope everyone's doing well. We wanted to continue with the organic investment question. I believe you launched some CITs in the quarter. So we are curious, which strategies did you put in these wrappers? Which client verticals are you targeting with the CITs and are you expecting some rotation out of the mutual fund wrapper in the identical strategy?
David Brown: We've made investments in products and product launches. We have launched a few ETFs and then we have a few on the docket for 2024. A good example of what we've done is, we've launched [V-Flow] (ph), which is an ETF that focuses on free cash flow. We've also launched MODL, which is a version of our WestEnd Advisors franchise. And so, when we think about going forward, we are thinking about launching, as you said, CITs and also ETFs. We have -- we're well experienced in the in the ETF side and we think that's an area where we can launch product and be pretty effective. And then, specifically on the CIT, we're targeting really retirement and institutional clients there. So a collective fund that our institutional clients can go into, and then also some of our retirement clients can go into some of the CITs as well.
Craig Siegenthaler: Thanks, Dave. For my follow-up, we wanted to dig a little deeper into your M&A commentary. I think you said you're evaluating numerous acquisition opportunities, some of that effect. So, it did sound a little more bullish than prior calls. So, maybe you could update us on size ranges and capability objectives. And I'm guessing that you're going to try to avoid product redundancies so you're generally focused on strategic versus consolidation?
David Brown: Yeah, we're quite optimistic that 2024 is going to be a year where we can execute a transaction. I use the term in my prepared remarks strategic and that would refer to something of size, and as far as product capabilities, redundancy, consolidation, I won't comment on any of that, but I will say that we're quite optimistic that 2024 is going to be a year where we can execute. We think the environment is a lot more friendly to doing acquisitions. We've got a really, really strong track record of the acquisitions we've done and how successful they've been. And we think 2024 is going to be a year where we can continue that. Nothing to report today, but we're making significant progress and we're bullish about it.
Craig Siegenthaler: Thank you, Dave.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Etienne Ricard from BMO Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Etienne Ricard: Thank you, and good morning. To follow up on the topic of acquisitions, for what asset class do you see the best opportunities? In other words, there's lots of discussion about an eventual improvement in fixed income net flows. Is this being reflected in potential transaction activity that you come across? And as a follow-up, do you see potential for a broader range of fixed income strategies at Victory?
David Brown: So, the way we look at acquisitions, we start off with a concept that does it make our company better. We don't specifically target asset classes. I think acquisitions are much wider and more in depth and more complicated than just trying to fill an asset class or a product capability. And so, we've never really approached it that we need a certain asset class. We do follow where our clients are going and that's how we've built our product lineup. So as far as acquisitions, as far as the acquisitions that we're looking at, I think it's a wide range of asset classes and types. And then in specific response to your question on fixed income, we have a really, really strong fixed income franchise. We've referenced the performance in our prepared remarks. And we feel really good about the lineup we have. There is a lot of assets moving into the private side of fixed income, private credit. That is an area that we're interested in. We don't have that capability today. The opportunity for us to go and get other fixed income capabilities. We're evaluating whether we do that internally, whether we partner with somebody, whether we acquire it. But if you look at the lineup we have today, I think it's quite compelling. And I also think it's very well positioned to capture assets when assets come out of the cash asset class and we're starting to see that today. We have a number of vehicles. We have ETFs that are driven by fixed income. We have mutual funds, institutional separate accounts, and all kinds of shared classes. So we feel really good about what we have today.
Etienne Ricard: Okay. And as a follow-up on the organic side, could you please share an update on your brokerage platform almost a year following the launch and the related improvements in client engagement that you've seen since? So, as you stated, we created a brokerage platform off of our direct business or direct channel and today clients can sign up for a brokerage account and perform basic brokerage activities, trade stocks, buy mutual funds in ETFs that aren't managed by Victory Capital. And we've seen great engagement with our clients. Our client service scores are excellent. We're starting to see clients sign up for brokerage accounts, move brokerage assets in there. And so, we're in the beginning phases of that. We look at that as a long-term build. We look at that as offering more products to our direct clients and then also potentially marketing to new clients. We look at the success of that over multiple years. And the phase we're in today is really around capabilities, around service, and we're doing an excellent job of both of those and we're starting to see some assets being raised on the brokerage side.
Etienne Ricard: Great. Thank you very much.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Alex Bolstein from Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.
Alex Bolstein: Hey, good morning guys. Thanks for the question. I wanted to follow-up on the comments you made around WestEnd advisors. It sounds like you made meaningful traction on kind of getting the product in front of financial advisors. I think the stat you cited something like up 35% in terms of the headcount. Can you help us frame the opportunity set within the sort of the addressable market that you kind of see there? So meaning advisors that utilize WestEnd, what's the average AUM maybe that they have under their umbrella and if others can get to a similar level, what kind of a flow and AUM uplift could that create for Victory? Just trying to get a little bit of a better framework to [indiscernible]. Thanks.
David Brown: Good morning, Alex. So when we acquired WestEnd, we had gone out and said that this was going to be an opportunity for us to grow their business and really for them to plug into our distribution capabilities. And so, since we've acquired them, which was really the beginning of 2022, they have been organic growth positive in every time period since inception. They were organic growth positive in 2023 and 2022. And part of that really is, as we've stated, is expanding the number of platforms that their product is on, and it's also increasing the number of advisors that are doing business with them. We've also increased their product set by launching their first ETF, MODL, which has been successful and allows advisors to access the WestEnd platform not just through the model delivery accounts. And so that area of the market has a lot of momentum. There are definitely opportunities that we will grow into and we'll grow into them a couple different ways. Typically what happens with a WestEnd client advisor is, they will start off small, and then they will eventually grow larger into the relationship. So the WestEnd product will capture a percentage of the advisors book and then over time the advisor will allocate more so there's really an opportunity to grow the existing relationship with advisors, get new advisors and then increase the platforms. I don't have a dollar amount I can share with you on the average AUM for an advisor or what the size of the market is, but if WestEnd is successful the way we think they will be, it'll be a material part of our organic growth story and the -- if you look at their growth historically and if you look at some of the projections for that part of the market and we capture what we think would be our share, it'll have an impact on our organic growth story.
Alex Bolstein: Yes. Okay. Excellent. And then just for a quick follow-up on the transaction and deal side of things. So based on your strategic comment, sounds like it'll be on the larger side. Can you just help us and remind what the leverage capacities on the balance sheet, how high you guys feel comfortable going in terms of debt to EBITDA?
Michael Policarpo: Good morning. Yes, I think we've never really set an exact level that we would commit to. I think we're very prudent in how we think about leverage and have been pretty fortunate in thinking about the ability to generate cash. We've also used a bunch of different tools as we've thought about M&A. The revenue sharing component for investment professionals, earn out components. Clearly we've used debt in the past as a marker for supporting the growth from an organic perspective. But at 2.0 times and the significant amount of cash that we do generate, we're comfortable with where we are and we're comfortable to expand that for the right deal. And so I think if you look backwards when we did the USA transaction, we were 2.6 times, 2.7 times. That's just the historical data point that I'd throw out there. I'm not suggesting that that's a cap. I'm not suggesting that that's a comfort level. But we have brought the leverage down in 2023 with the expansion of really both the earnings power as well as the cash accumulation to provide us flexibility. So I think we'll be prudent, but I think each deal is pretty specific and the facts and circumstances will kind of drive us from a structuring perspective, as well as kind of thoughts on leverage.
Alex Bolstein: Okay, thank you.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Adam Beatty from UBS. Please go ahead.
Adam Beatty: Thank you, and good morning. Just wanted to follow-up on some of the discussion around the CIT vehicle and maybe get some more details on your efforts in the retirement channel, how dialogues are going with either plan sponsors or other intermediaries and how much growth you see there. Thank you.
Michael Policarpo: Good morning. Yes, as Dave mentioned earlier, we have a pretty full suite of CIT offerings and have actually really going back to the MBO, so since 2013. As we've always said, we're pretty vehicle agnostic with respect to offering out our investment product through our different franchises. We think CITs are a great opportunity to penetrate the retirement platform network and have had success there really over the last several years as that more and more of an increasing opportunity from a vehicle perspective. Additionally, we also see it useful in institutional mandates. Some lower-end institutional clients can use CITs and we found that to be extremely beneficial to have that out there. We have a number of CITs out there across really more than a handful of our franchises. And getting placed on platforms with our CITs, getting placed on platforms with the various mutual fund share classes that we have as well as our ETF offerings really provides us a tremendous opportunity across different investor bases to capture assets, to capture the opportunities set from different financial advisors and retirement platforms. So it's been a staple for us and something that we think as macro environments have changed over time, will continue to be a growth engine for us moving forward, both in retirement as well as institutional.
David Brown: Yes. And Mike, I would add two things on that. I think one is, we do have a dedicated retirement sales group, and we've had that in place for years. And their sole focus is getting access on platforms and then servicing the platforms. And that sales cycle is quite long, but those are very sticky assets as those clients typically stay in your product over long periods of time. We also view that part of the market as an area that continues to grow and it's very predictable and we like that part of the market. So I think as we think about -- as Mike said, as we think about what product or what franchises we will launch in the retirement side, really I think it's really what the client demand will be.
Adam Beatty: Got it. Thanks, Dave. And as we head into the first quarter, which can sometimes be seasonally positive for retirement, would you expect an uplift [indiscernible] there?
David Brown: It's only through a month and a few days, so I'm not going to comment on what we're seeing or what we're not seeing. I would just say the retirement market is very predictable, even in times like this, where most investors are sitting on the sideline in cash.
Adam Beatty: Okay, makes sense. Thanks very much. Appreciate it.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Kenneth Lee from RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Kenneth Lee: Hey, good morning. Thanks for taking my question. Just broadly speaking, as you look further out this year, I wonder if you could just highlight any particular areas or strategies where you could see some potential organic growth opportunities, or like the best areas of potential organic growth opportunities out there. Thanks.
David Brown: Sure. So -- and in no specific or priority order, we think the WestEnd Advisors franchise and their model delivery business is -- has a lot of momentum and so we expect that part of our business to grow. RS Global has excellent investment performance and has made some headway in the institutional channel. That's another area. At some point in 2024, we think that our fixed income, franchise Victory income investors will see growth given some of the macro trends with assets moving parts of our ETF business as well. And that includes some of our fixed income ETFs we anticipate to grow. And then we have, I would say, a few capacity constrained asset classes where we have great investment performance with integrity in US small cap, RS Value in US small cap, and we think that those will be areas that will see some growth as well. Then generally speaking from a channel perspective, you know, our institutional distribution channel was net flow positive in the fourth quarter and we think that that's an area where we'll have momentum as well from a distribution perspective.
Kenneth Lee: Great, very helpful there. And just one follow-up, if I may, in terms of the potential M&A discussions you're having, any color around either bid-ask spread expectations or whether you've been seeing a change in seller expectations more recently. Thanks.
David Brown: I think each discussion is very unique to the opportunity. That being said, I think 2024 is going to be a year where we can execute and to execute you have to have buyer and seller expectations be close. And I'd say that what we're seeing from an environment perspective is, they've gotten a lot closer over the last quarter or so.
Kenneth Lee: Great. Very helpful there. Thanks again.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Michael Cyprys from Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Michael Cyprys: Hey, good morning. Thanks for taking the question. Just wanted to start off on the ETF franchise, nearly $5 billion of assets today. Maybe you could talk about some of the steps you're taking to accelerate growth and how built out is distribution and product set at this point compared to where you'd like to see that? Thanks.
David Brown: So, we have -- our ETF sales force is really part of our existing retail and intermediary sales force. So, our sales folks sell both mutual funds and ETF. We've just started to build out and to enhance that an ETF only salesforce. So that's something that we started in 2023 and will continue to build out in 2024. So we have all of our sales people out in the field really have the ability to talk about ETFs and to sell ETFs. We've launched a few new ETFs in 2023. We have plans to launch more in 2024. I would like to have more ETFs than not. I think that a portion of the buyers that maybe bought mutual funds before will look at ETFs. That doesn't mean that there aren't a lot of buyers for mutual funds, but clearly ETFs work well with certain types of clients in certain types of situations. We have had, we've been in the ETF business since 2015. So we're pretty well experienced. We understand it and under the Victory Shares brand, we think we can grow that business. And so, I would expect us to launch more ETFs in 2024 in a number of different asset classes and a number of different solution type, so really with different types of solutions for clients.
Michael Cyprys: Great, thanks. And just a follow-up question on the direct channel. If you could update us on how much in assets and accounts you have? What you saw in 2023 just in terms of flows and new account registrations, and just maybe you could talk about some of the steps you're taking in 2024 to accelerate growth and maybe just elaborate on the long-term vision you have for the direct channel? Thank you.
David Brown: So we don't disclose specific metrics for the direct channel as far as accounts or flows. So I won't report any of those but I'll give you some color. What we saw in 2023 and then going into 2024 really is building out capabilities. So building out our product set through the launch of the brokerage platform, ensuring that our service is of the highest standard, and also making sure that we work through all of the technology to make it a really good experience for clients when they sign up and our ability to service them. And longer term, what our vision is, is to have our existing client base have a really, really good experience, to have a wide set of products that go in addition to just Victory products, which was the thinking behind the brokerage launch. And I think, as we think about longer term as well, we think we can grow that business and really look at getting new clients and new assets. We do sign up a good number of new clients on the platform every day. And we have a lot of history talking to our clients and we're understanding what's important to them and addressing those issues. So as we continue to work through that, I think longer term, you'll see us have that channel and it will be an area where we're doing an excellent job and it should turn into significant or measurable growth.
Michael Cyprys: Great. Thank you.
Operator: Our final question today comes from Matthew Howlett from B. Riley. Please go ahead.
Matthew Howlett: Hey, thanks, everybody. Thanks for taking my question. Just on the subject of capital returns for 2024. I think investors get excited when they see the $243 million, 21% increase last year and with the dividend increase you're off to a head start in 2024. My question is on buybacks. How much will that depend on what you do on M&A? The stocks could easily hit a 52 week high today. I'd just love to hear what your thought is around buybacks and then with the M&A potentially occurring in 2014.
Michael Policarpo: Yes. Thanks, Matt. Yes, I think we've been very clear as we think about our capital policy and really has been unchanged. We want the flexibility to continue to execute our differentiated strategy, which really for us does include an organic growth. And so, we do look at, as you mentioned, we did increase our dividend this quarter about 5%, which we think is a strong reward for our shareholders and something that we still feel is ancillary to the overall picture from a business perspective. Really with respect to the balance between buybacks and M&A, really is facts and circumstances. So we do look at it ongoing. I think as we've said, we were active from an M&A perspective and we do think that's a differentiator for long-term value creation for our shareholders. In the absence of a pending M&A or something that sits right in front of us, we have done and executed on buybacks. So it really is a balance of looking at and across kind of all those components. You did mention we looked at in 2023, we did increase our buybacks. We were very opportunistic with respect to that. In our prepared remarks, we did mention that our board approved a $100 million buyback program in December. So we are ready and do have kind of all the tools to think about, both buybacks, M&A, as well as kind of dividends. So we're really trying to be balanced and looking at all of that. But it does really come with a perspective of facts and circumstances with what sits in front of us. And we feel like we've done a pretty good job of balancing all that to really drive that shareholder return and we'll continue to do that going forward.
David Brown: Yes. And you might just add to that, first and foremost always is, is making sure that our balance sheet is set up to support our strategic initiatives around acquisitions. And so ensuring that we have that, is first and foremost. And I think that's the best vehicle for shareholder return over the long term. But that being said, we are absolutely committed to returning capital to shareholders through dividends and also through buybacks. Our history shows that we've done a really good job balancing that out. And so, the acquisition environment impacts it, but we have the benefit of having a great business that throws off a lot of free cash flow and we have the benefit of having a lot of choices and being able to really to balance all of that and to do all of it. And so, that's the reward for having built a sizable business that has a lot of free cash flow is that, we can buy back a lot of shares, we can pay dividends and we can also do strategic acquisitions.
Matthew Howlett: Yes, and you have a great track record of buyback. I'm sure you look at your multiple versus peer group and see the value in buying back shares, but certainly the track record speaks to itself and congrats on both the dividend and the upsizing of the share repurchase program. The second question, the follow-up is just on, you always have the four platforms, RS, WestEnd, they always seem to be sort of the outperformers the last two quarters. Is there any secret sauce in the net outflow positive outcomes of those platforms versus the other subsidiaries or it's just going to ebb and flow or just there -- are they just always going to be sort of the outperformers to lead?
David Brown: I think there's a number of factors that goes into it quarter to quarter. It's very hard to look at the flow situation quarter-to-quarter. As I said earlier WestEnd has a really good product set, very competitive investment performance, and some industry tailwinds and good distribution. So we anticipate WestEnd will continue. RS Global is an area where we have a long-term track record. It is starting to gain momentum on the institutional side and it's a very competitive product. And there's a number of other franchises that will also ebb and flow, but I think you'll see more organic growth as the environment changes. The biggest headwind for us is the macro environment where investors are sitting in cash and not allocating to risk type investments. That will change. We don't know when it will change. I think we're getting a lot closer to that change. And when that change happens, I think we will be in a position to capture those assets as we've built the distribution channels over a number of years and we have really good investment performance and very competitive products.
Matthew Howlett: Great. Thanks, Dave.
Operator: That concludes our question-and-answer session. I will now turn the call back over to David Brown for closing remarks.
David Brown: Thank you. Later this month, On February 21st, we will be attending the Bank of America Securities 2024 Financial Services Conference in Miami. And on March 6, we'll be attending the RBC Capital Markets Global Financial Institutions Conference in New York. We look forward to seeing some of you at those events. Have a wonderful day and thanks for your interest in Victory Capital.
Operator: This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for your participation and you may now disconnect.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.