Advance Auto Parts’ SWOT analysis: stock turnaround faces uphill battle

Advance Auto Parts , Inc. (NYSE:AAP), a leading automotive aftermarket parts provider with a market capitalization of $2.9 billion, finds itself at a critical juncture as it attempts to navigate a challenging business landscape and execute a turnaround strategy. Recent analyst reports and company performance indicators paint a complex picture of AAP’s current position and future prospects. According to InvestingPro data, the company has maintained dividend payments for 20 consecutive years, demonstrating long-term financial commitment despite recent challenges.

Company Overview and Recent Performance

Advance Auto Parts operates in the U.S. Broadlines, Hardlines & Food Retail sector, providing automotive replacement parts, accessories, and maintenance items. The company has faced significant challenges in recent years, struggling to maintain consistent growth and profitability in a competitive market.

In the first quarter of 2025, AAP showed signs of progress towards rebuilding credibility by meeting its own set expectations. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) moved in a positive direction, indicating potential improvements in operational efficiency. The company’s current revenue stands at $8.9 billion, though InvestingPro analysis indicates the company was not profitable over the last twelve months, with a negative return on equity of -24%. Analysts remain cautious, citing the company’s long history of challenges and the need for sustained evidence of progress.

The fourth quarter of 2024 results, while showing sequential improvement, were still considered weak due to weather trends and competitor performance. This mixed performance underscores the company’s ongoing struggle to gain solid footing in the market.

Strategic Plan and Outlook

In late 2024, AAP’s management introduced a new strategic plan aimed at turning the company’s fortunes around. The plan focuses on creating a leaner core operation with a return to low single-digit comparable store sales growth, unit openings, and high single-digit margins. Analysts have noted that this new strategy appears more credible than previous attempts, potentially signaling a positive shift in the company’s direction.

As part of this plan, management has committed to sharing key performance indicators such as lines per hour, product availability rates, and average delivery times. This increased transparency may allow investors and analysts to better track the company’s progress and operational improvements.

Long-term financial targets for fiscal year 2027 include ambitious goals of $9 billion in sales and approximately 7% operating margin, which could potentially lead to earnings per share of around $7.00. While these targets represent significant growth from current levels, the company faces a challenging path to achieve them. InvestingPro analysis suggests the stock may be undervalued compared to its Fair Value, offering potential upside for investors willing to wait out the turnaround. For detailed valuation metrics and additional insights, check our comprehensive undervalued stocks list.

Financial Projections and Analyst Outlook

Analysts have made several adjustments to their financial projections for AAP based on recent performance and management commentary. For 2025, comparable sales are now expected to grow by 0.4%, up from a previous estimate of -0.1%. The 2026 projection remains at 1.0% growth. Adjusted earnings per share forecasts have been slightly increased to $1.08 for 2025 and $2.58 for 2026.

Despite these modest improvements in projections, analysts maintain a cautious stance. The consensus view appears to be one of "wait and see," with firms such as RBC Capital Markets and Barclays (LON:BARC) assigning "Sector Perform" and "Equal Weight" ratings, respectively. Current analyst targets range from $28 to $65, with 10 analysts recently revising their earnings expectations downward for the upcoming period, according to InvestingPro. This wider range reflects the uncertainty surrounding AAP’s turnaround efforts.

Industry Landscape and Competitive Position

AAP operates in a highly competitive industry, facing pressure from rivals such as O’Reilly Automotive (NASDAQ:ORLY) and AutoZone (NYSE:AZO). The company’s recent underperformance relative to competitors highlights the challenges it faces in regaining market share and improving operational efficiency.

The overall industry view is neutral, suggesting that while there may not be significant sector-specific headwinds, AAP cannot rely on strong industry tailwinds to aid its recovery. This places additional importance on the success of the company’s internal turnaround efforts.

Operational Improvements and Challenges

AAP’s management has identified several areas for operational improvement, including streamlining processes, enhancing product availability, and improving delivery times. The introduction of specific KPIs to track these improvements demonstrates a commitment to transparency and accountability.

However, the company faces significant challenges in executing its turnaround strategy. Ongoing changes within the organization create uncertainty in projecting improvements, and the back-end weighted guidance adds an element of risk to the company’s financial outlook.

Bear Case

Can AAP overcome its history of failed turnaround attempts?

Advance Auto Parts has a long history of challenges and unsuccessful turnaround efforts. This track record raises concerns about the company’s ability to execute its latest strategic plan effectively. Analysts remain cautious, preferring to wait for more consistent evidence of progress before recommending the stock. The company’s recent weak performance compared to competitors further underscores the difficulties it faces in regaining market share and improving profitability.

Will the back-end weighted guidance pose significant risks?

The company’s guidance is heavily weighted towards future performance, suggesting current instability and potential risks. This approach puts considerable pressure on AAP to deliver strong results in the latter part of its fiscal year. If the company fails to meet these back-loaded expectations, it could lead to significant disappointment among investors and potentially trigger a reevaluation of the stock’s prospects.

Bull Case

How might AAP’s operational improvements drive future growth?

AAP’s focus on key performance indicators such as lines per hour, product availability rates, and average delivery times could lead to significant operational improvements. If the company successfully enhances these metrics, it may result in increased efficiency, better customer satisfaction, and ultimately, improved financial performance. The commitment to transparency in reporting these KPIs also allows investors to track progress more effectively, potentially building confidence in the turnaround strategy.

Could low market expectations create an opportunity for outperformance?

Current expectations for Advance Auto Parts appear to be relatively low, which could create an opportunity for positive surprises if the company outperforms these modest forecasts. If AAP can demonstrate consistent progress in its turnaround efforts and exceed analyst projections, it may lead to a revaluation of the stock. The significant upside potential compared to current levels, as noted by some analysts, suggests that even a modest improvement in performance could result in substantial gains for investors.

SWOT Analysis

Strengths:

• Signs of progress in recent quarters
• New strategic plan with increased transparency
• Commitment to operational improvements

Weaknesses:

• History of failed turnaround attempts
• Weak recent performance compared to competitors
• Ongoing organizational changes creating uncertainty

Opportunities:

• Potential for margin expansion
• Room for comparable store sales growth
• Possible outperformance of low market expectations

Threats:

• Intense competition in the automotive aftermarket industry
• Execution risks associated with the turnaround strategy
• Potential for disappointing results due to back-end weighted guidance

Analysts Targets

• RBC Capital Markets (May 23rd, 2025): $44.00, Sector Perform
• Barclays (May 23rd, 2025): $54.00, Equal Weight
• Barclays (February 27th, 2025): $54.00, Equal Weight
• RBC Capital Markets (November 15th, 2024): $50.00, Sector Perform
• Barclays (November 15th, 2024): $66.00, Equal Weight

This analysis is based on information available up to May 26, 2025, and reflects the most recent analyst reports and company performance data provided. For deeper insights into AAP’s financial health, valuation metrics, and exclusive ProTips, explore our comprehensive Pro Research Report, available on InvestingPro. Our platform offers advanced analysis tools, Fair Value estimates, and expert insights to help you make more informed investment decisions.

InvestingPro: Smarter Decisions, Better Returns

Gain an edge in your investment decisions with InvestingPro’s in-depth analysis and exclusive insights on AAP. Our Pro platform offers fair value estimates, performance predictions, and risk assessments, along with additional tips and expert analysis. Explore AAP’s full potential at InvestingPro.

Should you invest in AAP right now? Consider this first:

Investing.com’s ProPicks, an AI-driven service trusted by over 130,000 paying members globally, provides easy-to-follow model portfolios designed for wealth accumulation. Curious if AAP is one of these AI-selected gems? Check out our ProPicks platform to find out and take your investment strategy to the next level.

To evaluate AAP further, use InvestingPro’s Fair Value tool for a comprehensive valuation based on various factors. You can also see if AAP appears on our undervalued or overvalued stock lists.

These tools provide a clearer picture of investment opportunities, enabling more informed decisions about where to allocate your funds.

This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.