Hedge funds are buying these two big tech stocks while selling two rivals
Introduction & Market Context
Kemper Corporation (NYSE:KMPR) released its third quarter 2025 earnings presentation on November 5, 2025, revealing results that fell significantly short of market expectations. The specialty insurer reported a net loss of $21.0 million, or $0.34 per diluted share, compared to analyst forecasts of $1.33 per share—representing a 75.19% miss. The stock closed down 2.56% at $43.75 following the announcement, though it recovered slightly in aftermarket trading, rising 1.49% to $44.40.
The company's presentation acknowledged that "results did not meet expectations" and outlined actions underway to improve profitability amid what it described as "a dynamic and evolving market." Despite revenue exceeding forecasts at $1.24 billion (3.33% above expectations), Kemper's earnings were heavily impacted by competitive pressures and elevated claims severity in its specialty auto business.
Quarterly Performance Highlights
Kemper's third quarter results showed mixed performance across its business segments. The company reported adjusted consolidated net operating income of $20.4 million, or $0.33 per diluted share, with return on equity (ROE) of -3.0% and adjusted ROE of -4.6%.
As shown in the following summary of key financial metrics:
The Specialty Property & Casualty segment, which focuses on underserved markets including Latino, Hispanic, and urban areas, faced significant challenges. While earned premiums grew 10.7% year-over-year to $1,017 million, the underlying combined ratio deteriorated to 99.6%, up from 91.3% in the same quarter last year. This increase was primarily driven by a higher underlying loss and LAE ratio of 78.5% compared to 70.1% in Q3 2024.
The following chart illustrates the performance metrics for the Specialty P&C segment:
In contrast, the Life Insurance segment delivered more consistent results, with adjusted net operating income increasing to $19 million from $15 million in Q3 2024. The segment, which targets low and moderate-income customers, maintained stable normalized revenues while improving key metrics such as average face value per policy and average premium per policy issued.
The Life segment's performance is detailed in this chart:
Sources of Volatility and Strategic Initiatives
Kemper's presentation provided a detailed breakdown of the factors affecting its quarterly results. The company identified several key items impacting its performance, including restructuring costs, impairment losses, and adverse prior year development in Commercial Auto.
As illustrated in this breakdown of volatility sources:
In response to these challenges, Kemper has launched a restructuring program aimed at enhancing organizational efficiencies. The initiative is expected to generate approximately $30 million in annualized run-rate savings, which the company plans to use to support profitability and growth in its Specialty Auto business.
The company's strategic focus remains on its core business model of serving specialty and underserved markets, where it believes it can develop sustainable competitive advantages through low-cost management, ease of use, distribution, and product sophistication.
This strategic positioning is illustrated in the company's business model:
Investment Portfolio & Capital Position
Despite operational challenges, Kemper maintained a strong balance sheet and capital position. The company reported parent company liquidity of over $1 billion and a debt-to-capital ratio of approximately 24%, which remains near its target range.
The following chart shows Kemper's capital position over time:
Kemper's investment portfolio continues to provide consistent returns, with a high-quality portfolio where 71% of fixed income investments are rated A or higher. The pre-tax equivalent annualized book yield on the core portfolio was 4.6%, while the average investment grade new money yield was approximately 6.2% for the quarter.
The composition and performance of Kemper's investment portfolio is shown here:
Forward-Looking Statements
Looking ahead, Kemper emphasized its focus on disciplined execution, operational excellence, and efficiency. The company is realigning its organization to position for success and implementing rate, non-rate, and expense initiatives to improve profitability and support growth.
The earnings call transcript revealed that Kemper anticipates a modest decline in total insurance in force by 1-3% in Q4 2025, with expectations for mid-single-digit growth in 2026. The company is particularly focused on expanding its presence in Florida and Texas.
Tom Evans, Kemper's Interim CEO, acknowledged the disappointing results but emphasized the company's commitment to enhancing competitive advantages and profitability through restructuring and improved execution. "We're reinforcing the disciplines that drive performance through management changes, a restructuring initiative, and a renewed focus on execution," Evans stated during the earnings call.
Analysts have raised concerns about challenges in the commercial auto segment, particularly regarding prior year development issues, as well as the potential impact of California's changing financial responsibility limits. The company faces ongoing challenges including increased competition in the specialty auto market, rising medical inflation, and elevated attorney involvement in claims, all of which could continue to pressure margins in the coming quarters.
Despite these challenges, Kemper's presentation emphasized its strong balance sheet with financial flexibility, which provides a foundation for navigating the current difficult market environment while implementing its strategic initiatives to return to profitability.
Full presentation:
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.